smartmontools

In line with my SysRq Post comes another bit of assumed knowledge, SMART. Let’s begin at the beginning (and stick to the PC world).

Magnetic storage is fault-prone. In the old days, when you formatted a drive, part of the formatting process was to check that each block seemed to be able to store data. All the bad blocks would be listed in a “bad block list” and the file-system would never try to use them. File-system checks would also be able to mark blocks as being bad.

As disks got bigger, this meant that formatting could take hours. Drives had also become fancy enough that they could manage bad blocks themselves, and so a shift occured. Disks were shipped with some extra spare space that the computer can’t see. Should the drive controller detect that a block went bad (they had parity checks), it could re-allocate a block from the extra space to stand in for the bad block. If it was able to recover the data from the bad block, this could be totally transparent to the file-system, if not the file-system would see a read-error and have to handle it.

This is where we are today. File-systems still support the concept of bad blocks, but in practice they only occur when a disk runs out of spare blocks.

This came with a problem, how would you know if a disk was doing ok or not? Well a standard was created called SMART. This allows you to talk to the drive controller and (amongst other things) find out the state of the disk. On Linux, we do this via the package smartmontools.

Why is this useful? Well you can ask the disk to run a variety of tests (including a full bad block scan), these are useful for RMAing a bad drive with minimum hassle. You can also get the drive’s error-log which can give you some indication of it’s reliability. You can see it’s temperature, age, and Serial Number (useful when you have to know which drive to unplug). But, most importantly, you can find out the state of bad sectors. How many sectors does the drive think are bad, and how many has it reallocated.

Why is that useful?

In the event of a bad block, you can manually force a re-allocation. This way it happens under your terms, and you’ll know exactly what got corrupted.

Next, Google published a paper linking non-zero bad sector values to drive failure. Do you really want be trusting known-non-trustworthy drives with critical data?

Finally, there is a nasty RAID situation. If you have a RAID-5 array with say 6 drives in it and one fails either the RAID system will automatically select a spare drive (if it has one), or you’ll have to replace it. The system will then re-build on the new disk, reading every sector on all the other disks, to calculate the sector contents for the new disk. If one of those reads fails (bad sector) you’ll now be up shit-creek without a paddle. The RAID system will kick out the disk with the read failure, and you’ll have a RAID-5 array with two bad disks in it — one more than RAID-5 can handle. There are tricks to get such a RAID-5 array back online, and I’ve done it, but you will have corruption, and it’s risky as hell.

So, before you go replacing RAID-5 member-disks, check the SMART status of all the other disks.

Personally, I get twitchy when any of my drives have bad sectors. I have smartd monitoring them, and I’ll attempt to RMA them as soon as a sector goes bad.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The trick foor dealing with >1 disk failure

Seeing as I’ve been asked, the trick for dealing with multiple disk failures is:

Firstly, we have to assume that they are soft-failures, i.e. a disk got kicked out because of a bad sector. You were re-adding it, when another drive also picked up a bad read, and got kicked too.

Now, because of bad sectors on multiple drives we are going to have corruption, but so be it.

The array can’t be started any more, and disks can’t be added to it, because both kicked disks are marked as dirty.

So you have to work out the correct order, and do a mdadm --create with exactly the right options (you can determine them from the md super-blocks). You do this with N-1 disks so it is started degraded, and no re-syncing occurs. If it looks sane, you add another disk, resync (you’ve already dealt with those bad sectors, right?), fsck, and then go looking for corruption.

When I did this, it was with reiserfs, and one of the disks in the rebuild had been out of the array for a day or so (it was the best we could do). Although I got hundreds of fsck errors (and fsck-ing reiserfs is never pretty) we never found any real data corruption on the volume. I was rather impressed.

Shop hotels look for to blend

Shop hotels look for to blend the environment of luxury provided by global resort organisations using the personalised service supplied by its scaled-down cousins. At the start of the present global economic downturn in 08, the journey industry -- which experienced experienced buoyant growth throughout the boom many years - braced itself for any downturn. asiaboutiqueresorts.com

I truly feel evaluating white

I truly feel evaluating white and black digital cameras with it's movie comparable is a lot like looking at apples with grapefruits. They merely are certainly not the same in feel and look. have a peek at this web-site I mentioned this in depth partly 1 with this range. When speaking to photographer Hellen Vehicle Meene she explain motion picture as getting "magic". Now I'm not sure exactly what the techical phrase for wonder is but creatively I know exactly what Hellen implies.

I really enjoy simply reading

I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. facebook hacker

Nice article, thanks for

Nice article, thanks for sharing. Generate Bitcoins Online

Everything is very open and

Everything is very open and very clear clarification of issues. It contains truly facts. Your website is very valuable. Thanks for sharing. High Pagerank Backlinks
Buy High Pagerank Backlinks
High Pagerank Backlinks

And looming large in my eyes

And looming large in my eyes and in those of everyone else in attendance were these huge breasts of a pyramid beast woman, recast as reproductive machine. how to be rich

If you are a lover of cats

If you are a lover of cats then the online cat shop can help you in getting this animal that you love in the easiest of manners. If you are a lover of dogs then the online dog shop would help you in owning a dog easily. www.mypetshop.org

Amazon Login

You can see it’s temperature, age, and Serial Number (useful when you have to know which drive to unplug). But, most importantly, you can find out the state of bad sectors. How many sectors does the drive think are bad, and how many has it reallocated. Amazon Login

I really appreciate that you

I really appreciate that you wrote this article and shared some really good information on this specific topic. I was in vital need to get some information on this topic and thanks to you, I've got that! Thanks, once again! american home warranty
total protect home warranty

Great website here, really

Great website here, really useful and interesting information. Thanks a lot for all your efforts, and please keep the great work up!
Tips Cepat Hamil - yamaha r15 dan yamaha r25 motor sport racing dan kencang - camry mobil hybrid terbaik indonesia - asus zenfone smartphone android terbaik - cipto junaedy

You have raised a paramount

You have raised a paramount issue..thanks for sharing..i might want to peruse more present issues from this blog.. keep foredi posting..

If it was able to recover the

If it was able to recover the data from the bad block, this could be totally transparent to the file-system, if not the file-system would see a read-error and have to handle it. Gary Deardorff

When I did this, it was with

When I did this, it was with reiserfs, and one of the disks in the rebuild had been out of the array for a day or so (it was the best we could do). Although I got hundreds of fsck errors (and fsck-ing reiserfs is never pretty) we never found any real data corruption on the volume. I was rather impressed. Click for information

They need to be stored

They need to be stored separated on floured trays, and turned twice every day to avoid sticking to each other or the trays. However, they should taste delicious tomorrow night. backlinks service

Hey there thanks for showing

Hey there thanks for showing me this. I must say that your blogpost was the most enjoying read I've seen in a long time. Greetings from дизайн интерьера Москва
дизайн интерьера Москва
дизайн интерьера Москва
дизайн интерьера Москва

I really enjoy simply reading

I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful.
stop loss order
stop loss order
stop loss order
stop loss order

Thanks for such an

Thanks for such an interesting article here. asvab for dummies

pikavipithetitilille.fi

I decipher your inform plus I build it extraordinary .Your notion process is fabulous. pikavipithetitilille.fi

it just remounts them R/O.

it just remounts them R/O. That said, it certainly seems like an emergency_sync() after emergency_remount() is useless; it might also be useless before-hand, but at least it'll actually do something that way. https://www.rebelmouse.com/

I really enjoy simply reading

I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful. contoh soalan peperiksaan penguasa kastam w41

Finally, there is a nasty

Finally, there is a nasty RAID situation. If you have a RAID-5 array with say 6 drives in it and one fails either the RAID system will automatically select a spare drive (if it has one), or you’ll have to replace it. www.rsiandassociates.com

If you live in New South

If you live in New South Wales, for example, you can easily use an online pet services directory to find a breeder, a pet shop, or a vet in your area. www.petsspark.org

A few hundred ravioli. It

A few hundred ravioli. It selects the defeat department of an afternoon, you possess to process altogether swift, also the peremptory item doesn't celebrate same well. venus factor system reviews

The owners of most businesses

The owners of most businesses want their customers properly informed of all products, maintenance and best practice. You'll notice in a lot of pet stores that fish tanks normally take up all the wall space, in other words there are lots of them. Why? Because they're very popular. www.select4pets.org

Some of the most commonly

Some of the most commonly found range of jewelleries includes gold jewellery, silver jewellery, studded jewellery, colourful, chunky pieces of jewellery and much more. www.fashionismydrug.org

I really feel assessing black

I really feel assessing black and white portrait digital photography with it's movie equal is similar to assessing apples with grapefruits. They just usually are not the same thing in feel and look. I reviewed this in more detail to some extent 1 of this range buy instagram likes . When speaking to professional photographer Hellen Vehicle Meene she identify video as experiencing "wonder". Now I'm unclear just what the techical word for wonder is but artistically I understand what exactly Hellen means.

All visitors are benefited to

All visitors are benefited to read this sit’s article. All article is Unique and relevant. restore my vision

Some of the most commonly

Some of the most commonly found range of jewelleries includes gold jewellery, silver jewellery, studded jewellery, colourful, chunky pieces of jewellery and much more,,..
buy facebook likes

I just got to this amazing

I just got to this amazing site not long ago. I was actually captured with the piece of resources you have got here. Thank you so much. Keep up the good works.venus factor diet plan

The enjoyable experience &

The enjoyable experience & easy to navigate of the customer's offers an added value which inturn helps the portals to get more new buyers. Giving customers' a lot of options in brands, discount rates & offers also pulls in a number of various visitors. www.florenceshopping.org

Hey there thanks for showing

Hey there thanks for showing me this. I must say that your blogpost was the most enjoying read I've seen in a long time. Greetings from personal trainer munich

bli omdirigerad hit That's an

bli omdirigerad hit

That's an interesting point... could you elaborate more on that please?

I agree with you. This post

I agree with you. This post is truly inspiring. I like your post and everything you share with us is current and very informative, I want to bookmark the page so I can return here from you that you have done a fantastic job. how to be rich
how to be rich
how to be rich
how to be rich

I was also searching related

I was also searching related stuff from long time.You have solved my problem.Thanks for sharing this great stuff with us High Pagerank Backlinks
High PR Backlinks

it is so wonderful trip you

it is so wonderful trip you had. Really thank you for sharing the true information with us. The map shown in the picture looks not scaled. is it a old map. I hope you will share some pictures of your amazing hike. Thank you for sharing. http://archive.org

Nice posting... | guest house

Great posting... | homestay

Well a standard was created

Well a standard was created called SMART. This allows you to talk to the drive controller and (amongst other things) find out the state of the disk. On Linux, we do this via the package pull yor ex back

One tip that can help you

One tip that can help you study in college is to make yourself flash cards when you have an exam coming up. Flash cards are easy to make. Your can buy inexpensive index cards and write questions on one side and answers on the other. You and a classmate can then use them to study together.

Be prompt when you are applying for grants or scholarships. When you apply early, there is a better chance you will receive more funds. Make sure that all documentation and fees are submitted in the proper time frame. Text Your Ex Back by Michael Fiore

Make sure to make time for

Make sure to make time for both socializing and academics. Some students spend all their times in their dorm rooms studying, which can be depressing and lonely, while others are so social that their coursework suffers. You should get out of your room and do something fun at least once a week and devote at least an hour a night to studying for each of your classes to help you stay balanced. pull your ex back

Current and prospective

Current and prospective college students have many important things to consider. There are plenty of things to learn about going to college, and it's important that you go over some tips prior to getting into school. The tips below will help your prepare for college. tao of badass pdf

Being successful and

Being successful and graduating from college is not just a walk in the park. It takes a bit of hard work, perseverance and many other qualities. This can be especially hard for many students due to all the temptations and new freedom. Use the advice below to get the most from your college education while still having fun. magnetic messaging review

Improve the outside of your

Improve the outside of your home by landscaping with plants native to your geographical region. Native plants are proven to do well in your climate, so the long-term results are predictable. You can plan your landscape with confidence that the look you want to achieve will be the look you get. If you choose non-native plants instead, there is a risk that the plants may not thrive in your climate. family survival course review

RAID choice

For this reason alone, despite it being so much more expensive, RAID 10 is looking so much more worth it these days. o.O

The particular Hotel provides

The particular Hotel provides and will be offering a elegant quality service to all or any clientele capturing diversity wants conforming to fulfill the demands of each individual and also corporate consideration. Spreading out there a meal of selection of Banquet and also rooms holiday accommodation, that product the would like and wants from live-in, live-out class package, meeting, meeting, hotelsandresort.com

klikke på dette link her

I agree with you. This post

I agree with you. This post is truly inspiring. I like your post and everything you share with us is current and very informative, I want to bookmark the page so I can return here from you that you have done a fantastic job. дизайн студия интерьера
дизайн интерьера Москва

give you some indication of

give you some indication of it’s reliability. You can see it’s temperature, age, and Serial Number (useful when you have to know which drive to unplug). But, most importantly, you can find out the state of bad sectors. How many sectors does the drive think are bad, and how many has it reallocated.
cheap san antonio bail bonds

cloud storage comparison It

cloud storage comparison It was nice to know about the smartmontools. I had no idea that bad block can be manually reallocated and the disk that are now available in the market are capable of doing the recovery themselves. Hope that such tools will be shared here often.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.